• Why ‘non toxic’ nail polish may still be harming you and the environment

    August 15, 2019 • BEAUTY

    safe nail polish

    It started as “3 free”…removing from nail polish the toxic trio of dibutyl phthalate, toluene, and formaldehyde.  Now, we see up to “13 free” polishes marketed as if the higher the number, the healthier they are for you; with many promoted as “eco”, “natural” and “healthy” because of what they leave out. Yet, while the brands tell you what they don’t contain, most are not upfront about what they do still contain. And, there is no common standard for the “x free” claims, so a 10 free may still in fact contain something that a 5 free leaves out!

    Feeling unsettled? We were too, so Biome has decided to step away and remove all nail polishes from our store because they contain chemicals that we will not accept in any other product in our stores.  We know many of our customers love to wear to nail polish, so we have until now offered the less toxic of the options. But, we take our strict standards seriously and we are no longer comfortable glossing over these synthetic ingredients in nail polish.

    Biome’s mission is to help solve the world’s environmental crisis by empowering you to see through the greenwash and provide solutions that are better for you and the planet.

    Painted nails on a special occasion are a joyful thing for many, us included! Please enjoy when you do. Our aim is to educate about the whole story, as fully informed consumers are empowered consumers, and that is when real change happens.

    We look forward to promoting a more natural and environmentally-sound nail care approach and hope you will join us on this journey. See our tips at the end of this post on how you can achieve naturally beautiful nails!

    What is “x free” nail polish?

    In this post we delve more deeply into the chemicals that are still used in “x free” nail polish.  For this article we refer to “x free” as the popular polishes in Australia touted as non-toxic, natural, healthy, plant-based or breathable because of what they leave out.  We compared those polishes with several “regular nail polishes”.  As you’ll read below, we discovered that the ingredients are for the most part the same!

    Part of the problem is when brands remove certain chemicals to be “free of”, what are they replaced by? Is the substitution just as toxic? It’s hard to know because of the 1000’s of chemicals used in cosmetics very few have ever had full safety testing.

    A study from the Harvard University T.H. Chan School of Public Health in 2018, raised this issue. The study co-author said it was like playing a game of chemical tiggy, where one toxic chemical was removed and you ended up chasing down the next potentially harmful chemical substituted in. (1,2)

    We hope to empower you with a greater understanding of what makes up nail polish so you can look past the buzzword claims and make your choice based on the actual ingredients.

    How is nail polish made?

    Nail polish is a liquid that sets to a hard substance when exposed to the air. This happens because the solvent evaporates.

    A film-forming polymer (plastic) is dissolved in a solvent (often an alcohol) with the most common being nitrocellulose that is dissolved in butyl acetate and ethyl acetate. Every one of both the “x free” and regular polishes we looked at started with these three same ingredients, as you can see in the table below.

    Plasticisers are added to make the film pliable and less brittle, such as the banned dibutyl phthalate, camphor, and isosorbide dicaprylate.

    Dyes, pigments, opalescents such as chromium oxide greens, ferric ferrocyanide, titanium dioxide, carmine, mica, bismuth oxychloride, natural pearls, and alumina, fish scales.

    Adhesive polymers to adhere the nitrocellulose adheres to the nail’s surface: such as tosylamide-formaldehyde resin.

    Thickening agents to keep the sparkling particles in suspension: commonly stearalkonium hectorite.

    Ultraviolet stabilisers resist colour changes when the dry film is exposed to sunlight: commonlybenzophenone-1.

    Fragrance to mask the smell and preservative.

    What we found

    The ingredients in every polish we looked at, both those touted as x free/non toxic/healthy/natural and the regular well-known brands (such as OPI, Revlon, Covergirl, Sally Hansen), were remarkably similar!  Note, that we did not look at any ‘no name’, cheap imported brands that we recommend avoiding in all instances.

    Notably, the first three ingredients were the exact same for every polish: Ethyl Acetate, Butyl Acetate, and Nitrocellulose. And, the next few ingredients were almost the same with a few differences in the order: Acetyl Tributyl Citrate, Adipic Acid/Neopentyl Glycol/Trimellitic Anhydride Copolymer, Isopropyl Alcohol. As ingredients must be listed in order of most quantity to least, our estimation is that approximately 85% percent of the ingredients are the same whether a regular nail polish or an “x free”.

    Ingredients known to be irritants, suspected of harm, and environmental toxins that are restricted in some countries, were found in all polishes.

    Concerning ingredients found in the regular polishes that were not in any of the “x free” included: Tetrabutyl Phenyl Hydroxybenzoate, Tosylamide/Epoxy Resin, Synthetic Fluorphlogopite, and the plasticiser Triphenyl Phosphate (TPHP) which is one of those introduced to replace the initial toxic trio, but is also suspected to be a reproductive and endocrine toxicant.

    Conversely, petroleum-derived irritants found in the “x free” brands that did not appear in the regular brands included: Propylene Glycol, Polyurethane-67, PET, Glyceryl Linoleate, and Polymethyl Methacrylate.

    The most concerning ingredient Benzophenone-1, a known endocrine disruptor, was found in three of the supposedly more safe “x free” polishes and some of the regular.

    A side note, we also observed that many brands and online retailers selling nail polish products do not display the full list of ingredients at the point of sale on the website (considered best practice by the ACCC), rather they only put the “does not contain” list!

    Ingredients of high concern in “x free/healthy” nail polishes

    Benzophenone-1: Human endocrine disruptor – strong evidence (European Union). One or more studies show significant wildlife and the environment disruption. Human skin toxicant or allergen – strong evidence.

    N-Butyl Alcohol: Found in every nail polish we looked at. Known human lung, skin, eye skin toxicant and irritant (EU). Classified as expected to be toxic or harmful (Environment Canada Domestic Substance List). Of particular concern for those working in Nail Salons who are exposed it all day because EU regulates that workplace exposure is restricted to low doses.

    Dimethicone: Recommended restricted in cosmetics. Suspected to be an environmental toxin and be persistent or bioaccumulative (Environment Canada Domestic Substance List)

    Propylene Glycol: Skin, eye or lung irritant, organ system toxicity, penetration enhancer.

    Buzzwords

    We discovered there are few differences between the polishes marketed as less toxic and regular polishes, and yet these are the kinds of claims being made to differentiate the brands:

    Natural & organic
    Healthy polish
    Alternative to regular nail polish
    Eco polish
    Toxin free
    Ethical
    Kind on you and kind on the planet
    Properties of the plant materials imparting benefits despite their chemical composition being radically altered, and once applied to the nail they either evaporate or can not escape the polymer film.

    Our assessment table

    This table summarises all the ingredients we found in “x free” polishes and compared whether they are also found in regular polishes.

    EWG rating: refers to EWG’s Skin Deep Database found at www.ewg.org  Note that a “1” is the lowest hazard rating they give, but does not mean that it is safe nor natural, and must be assessed together with the data availability. Most of those with 1 rating are synthetic, petroleum-derived ingredients and they can still be an irritant or have ecological toxicity.

    Reg: refers to the regular nail polishes we assessed (such as OPI, Revlon, Covergirl, Sally Hansen). We grouped and marked here if the ingredient was generally found.

    A – G columns: a column for each of the nail polishes marketed as being healthier, eco, natural, ethical, “x free” options that we assessed.

    Ingredient Assessment of X Free Nail Polish

    X Free Non Toxin Nail Polish Ingredient Assessment

    X Free Nail Polish Assessment

    How to achieve naturally beautiful nails

    Beautiful ‘buff’ nails is all about giving your hands, feet and nails a whole lotta love, and nurturing their natural beauty, rather than covering up what you may see as imperfections.

    Nails that constantly break or peel could signal being dried out. Frequent hand washing, washing the dishes, laundry and house cleaning, gardening, frequent manicures, hand sanitiser, dry weather, and even not drinking enough water, can all contribute to nails drying out.

    In our blog post here we step you through 5 ways to look after your nails naturally, including some easy DIY recipes.

    Sources:
    1) https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/hsph-in-the-news/nontoxic-nail-polish-may-still-contain-toxins/
    2) https://time.com/5419483/nail-polish-chemicals/

    4 Responses to Why ‘non toxic’ nail polish may still be harming you and the environment
    1. Pingback: How to achieve naturally beautiful buff nails | Biome Eco Stores

    2. Bron Walker
      August 16, 2019 at 8:12 am

      Fantastic article. Had no idea nail polish is so toxic! I need to rethink my use of it.

    3. August 16, 2019 at 8:21 am

      Thank you!
      Such a comprehensive post. So thorough and informative. I was thinking my nail choices were vegan and cruelty free but if the polish contains any of these chemicals, surely they are tested on animals? I’m just going to have to take your advice and work on my natural nails looking good 🙂 Thanks again 🙂

    4. Vanessa Mather
      August 16, 2019 at 11:03 am

      Excellent article. I gave up using nail polish years ago because of my concerns about animal testing and using toxic chemicals. With the explosion of nail salons, I often wonder about the health effects on the nail technicians working there.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *